How I Put An End To Sensitive Teeth With Homemade Toothpaste

I used to have sensitive teeth. I used to use a maximum strength sensitive toothpaste. I used to use a numbing gel I got from my dentist everyday. And I STILL had sensitive teeth & gums. And then I started making DIY, nontoxic, homemade toothpaste. My sensitive teeth are a thing of the past. Bye bye, Sensodyne!

This is a simple DIY toothpaste recipe that you can make in about 5 minutes with just a few ingredients. This toothpaste recipe  is effective, inexpensive, easy to make, all natural, good for sensitive teeth, whitens, remineralizes, and smells great! 

The Problem With Toothpastes For Sensitive Teeth (well, with most commercial toothpastes actually....)

Here are some ingredients in the sensitive toothpaste I used:

  • Sodium Fluoride
    • Developmental/reproductive toxicity, Irritation (skin, eyes, or lungs), & Organ system toxicity (non-reproductive). A toxic score of 5.
  • Flavor
    • Flavor is a term used by cosmetic manufacturers for substances or combination of substances added to a cosmetic product to produce or to mask a particular flavor. A toxic score of 4.
  • Cocamidoprophyl Betaine
    • Cocamidopropyl betaine is a synthetic surfactant; it has been associated with irritation and allergic contact dermatitis, reactions that could be due to the ingredient itself or to impurities present in it, such as 3-dimethylaminopropylamine. A toxic score of 4.

The MAIN problem with my sensitive toothpaste was that it DID NOT CURE anything for me.

I still had sensitive teeth & gums. Everyday. 

I used that toothpaste for several years and my sensitivity never decreased and actually got worse. 

It got so bad that my dentist then gave me a numbing gel with fluoride that I applied to my gums everyday.  I was brushing my teeth with a fluoride toothpaste and then rubbing a fluoride gel on my gums. 

Fluoride has been linked to acne, rashes, arthritis, and thyroid problems.  Over 400 studies have concluded that fluoride is a neurotoxin and negatively affects the brain. 

And according to the EPA:

Adults exposed to excessive consumption of fluoride over a lifetime may have increased likelihood of bone fractures, and may result in effects on bone leading to pain and tenderness. For effects to teeth, children are most likely to be affected by excessive exposure to fluoride because it impacts teeth while they are still in formative phases. Children aged 8 years and younger exposed to excessive amounts of fluoride have an increased chance of developing pits in the tooth enamel, along with a range of cosmetic effects to teeth. 

My dental history is far from flawless. I had periodontal disease and a root canal at the age of 20. I was blessed with an impressive overbite and had some form of metal in my mouth for 13 years (an appliance as a kid, braces for middle & high school, upper removable retainer, & lower permanent retainer for early adulthood). I believe this was one of the factors that caused my gum problems. It is difficult to clean behind all that metal & wires.

I thought I was doing the best thing for my oral health using the sensitive toothpaste and numbing gel. 

Nope. I was making things worse.

I have not had a single problem or sensitivity since ditching commercial toothpaste!

diy toothpaste recipe that works for sensitive teethdiy toothpaste recipe that works for sensitive teethdiy toothpaste recipe that works for sensitive teeth

DIY Homemade Toothpaste Recipe for Sensitive Teeth:


how to use bentonite clay for health and beautyhow to use activated charcoal for whiter teeth, health, and beauty
essential oils for oral health, homemade toothpaste, and oil pulling


  • Mix all ingredients together. Heat the coconut oil on the stove on low if it needs to be melted a little. 
  • Store in a cute jar
  • This is shelf stable so store in your bathroom and use every time you brush your teeth.

Why This Natural Toothpaste Works

All of these ingredients are safe, natural, and nontoxic.

It's not a problem if it's swallowed so your kids can safely use it. 

Homemade Toothpaste Q&A

  • Will my teeth turn the color of the clay?
    • NO! It will not. My teeth are whiter than ever. And I am a coffee and red wine drinker.
  • Is the clay safe with metal fillings?
    • Yep! From the clay manufacturer: "We have found that a short period of time with metal is not enough to cause a reaction, such as brushing your teeth, or mixing the clay with a spoon. You would not want to leave a spoon in clay for a long period of time, or leave clay packed on a tooth with a filling, but for brushing you are perfectly safe."
  • Can I use something other than xylitol?
    • Yes. You can use stevia, honey, or no sweetner at all.
  • Is it safe for kids?
    • Yes. Everything is natural. My son used it when he was little.

Update & Bonus Hack!

I used this amazing recipe for several years. 

Then I found Thieves toothpaste

Easy button! Thieves toothpaste is made with very similar ingredients and my dentist loves it! My family uses the Aromabright, Whitening, & KidScents Toothpastes. 

And bonus, I use the Aromabright Toothpaste as my deodorant. Read more about that here

Check out these Thieves Toothpaste testimonies: 

thieves essential oil for teeth and oral healththieves essential oil for teeth and oral healththieves essential oil for teeth and oral health

Bonus Tip: Oil Pulling

Oil pulling is a magical detox that is great for oral health. Read more about it here.

oil pulloing guide and benefits of oil pullinghow to make oil pulling chews to whiten teeth

More Posts on Holistic Oral Health:

Get a free copy of The Beauty Remix!

If you love this recipe & want more like it, click here to get a free copy of my eBook The Beauty Remix! Loaded with DIY recipes you'll love! 

Pin this article to save it for later!

Also check out:

nail strengthening serum with essential oilshow to start the no poo method natural hair carediy deodorant recipe that works with coconut oil, baking soda, and essential oils
detox bath recipes with epsom salts and essential oilsGOOT garlic oil ointment treatmentmaster cleanse shot with apple cider vinegar, lemon juice, honey, and turmeric